Picasa vs. iPhoto vs. Flickr vs. Panoramio
Earlier I mentioned that I have some photos uploaded to Panoramio. I’ve also played with Flickr off and on, and have recently started uploading some photos there as well. To add to the confusion, I use Picasa to manage photos on my hard drive, and my wife uses iPhoto on her Mac. Picasa has a web albums feature, and I’m sure iPhoto has something similar with a .Mac account.
Why use four different services that overlap each other to such a degree? Picasa and iPhoto both do the important job of managing photos locally, Flickr seems to have the largest community and the most widgets written for it, and Panoramio integrates with Google Earth. Since I want to do all those things, I have to use them all.
There are ways to make them play nice together. You can use a Gmail account to email photos from Picasa to Flickr, and so far it seems to work fairly well. There are a few iPhoto plugins to upload to Flickr and you can use iPhoto to subscribe to Flickr photostreams. Google just bought Panoramio, so I’m sure there will be more integration there soon as well.
Even with all these options, there are some annoyances. Picasa’s keyword tagging is not very useful, it only allows one-word tags. I tried creating multi-word tags with dashes or by enclosing them in quotes, but Picasa ate the special characters. There’s also the complication of managing public photos vs private photos.
Still, it is amazing how well these different websites and programs work together, through the magic of RSS, web API, and plain old email.
If you’d like, you can see my Flickr photos here. You can also see my photos in Panoramio, or just look close enough in Google Earth, since a few of my photos now how up there.
Sphere: Related ContentTags: Blog, Flickr, Google, iPhoto, Panoramio, Photography, Picasa, RSS, Web2.0
February 13th, 2008 at 11:07 pm
[...] No matter the particular photo site used, sharing photos online has been a great experience. I’ve had a number of encouraging comments on my photos and people have emailed me to ask if they could use a photo in a report for school or a pamphlet for their non-profit. [...]
February 25th, 2008 at 12:39 am
[...] 2: Now tell the group to act like it’s the best day of their lives. Take the picture, upload it to Flickr or whatever you use, and bask in the many kudos you will [...]
July 6th, 2008 at 4:08 am
[...] 200mm. Another thing I’ll be looking into is automating geotagging – I’m a big fan of photo sharing systems like Flickr and Picasa and it would be great to have faster, more accurate place data on [...]
August 16th, 2008 at 4:30 am
I use those 3 services two. I like Flickr for their community and the well-designed website. In Picasa you can store more pictures (Flickr is 200 pictures, Picasa is 1GB of pictures). I do like Google Earth more than Yahoo’s map app and because the pictures in Picasa don’t show up in Google Earth and the pictures in Panoramio do (Google, why is that, you own both ??) I also use Panoramio.. I wish I only had to use 1….
September 11th, 2008 at 5:00 pm
[...] I did find this article and this one, and this one very interesting, if anyone else is having the same issues as me. Tags: flickr, photos, picasa [...]
October 2nd, 2008 at 2:05 pm
[...] http://www.jasonmorrison.net/content/2007/picasa-vs-iphoto-vs-flickr-vs-panoramio/ [...]